Free shipping for continental U.S. orders over $69.00. Call us at 800-998-3473 for rates to Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico & Canada.

Jelly, Preserves, Peanut Butter & Chutney

Hot Pepper Jellies not only make an awesome PB&J sandwich but they are great served over cream cheese or when used as a glaze! Some of our jelly flavors include Backyard Hot Pepper Peach Jelly and Heinie Hurtin' Jalapeño Hot Sauce & Jelly!

Grid List

Set Descending Direction

1-10 of 37

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  1. Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter - 13 ounce jar
    $8.99

    SKU:JE10

    Market Price $9.99

    Our Low Price $8.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $23.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $7.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $83.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $6.99

    Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter - Salty and spicy, Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter is an all-natural, creamy peanut butter made with Ass Kickin' Peanuts. This medium-heat peanut butter adds a fun kick to PB&J and other recipes when swapped out for regular peanut butter. Try using it in a Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe.

    From Arizona

    Ingredients: Peanuts roasted in peanut oil with added salt, spices, Habaero Pepper & extractive of paprika.

    Learn More
  2. Backyard Red Hot Pepper Jelly - 9.8 ounce jar
    $8.49

    SKU:JE200

    Our Low Price $8.49

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $22.47 - Save $3.00 Bottle Price $7.49

    Fantastic Price for 12 Bottles $77.88 - Save $24.00 Bottle Price $6.49

    Backyard Red Hot Pepper Jelly - Sweet with heat made from a winning mix of peppers with a delightful "sweet-hot" taste. Give your pork, chicken or cream cheese a sweet heat flair with this Red Hot Pepper Jelly.

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Peppers, cane sugar, vinegar & pectin.

    Learn More
  3. Backyard Screamin' Green Habaero Hot Pepper Jelly - 9.7 ounce jar
    $8.49

    SKU:JE219

    Our Low Price $8.49

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $22.47 - Save $3.00 Bottle Price $7.49

    Fantastic Price for 12 Bottles $77.88 - Save $24.00 Bottle Price $6.49

    Backyard Screamin' Green Habaero Hot Pepper Jelly - Sweet with heat made from a winning mix of peppers with a delightful "sweet-hot" taste. Give your pork, chicken or cream cheese sweet heat flair with this Screamin' Green Habaero Hot Pepper Jelly.

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Cane sugar, Habaero peppers, vinegar & pectin.

    Learn More
  4. Backyard Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly - 9.7 ounce jar
    $8.49

    SKU:JE213

    TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK

    SCROLL DOWN TO PURCHASE SIMILAR ITEMS

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $8.49

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $22.47 - Save $3.00 Bottle Price $7.49

    Fantastic Price for 12 Bottles $77.88 - Save $24.00 Bottle Price $6.49

    Backyard Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly - Sweet and heat made from a winning mix of strawberries and peppers with a delightful "sweet-hot" taste. Give your pork, chicken or cream cheese a home sweet home flare with the Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly.

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Strawberries, Chili peppers, cane sugar, vinegar & pectin.

    Learn More
  5. Backyard Tomato Hot Pepper Jelly - 9.7 ounce jar
    $8.49

    SKU:JE212

    Our Low Price $8.49

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $22.47 - Save $3.00 Bottle Price $7.49

    Fantastic Price for 12 Bottles $77.88 - Save $24.00 Bottle Price $6.49

    Backyard Tomato-Hot Pepper Jelly - Sweet with heat made from a winning mix of tomatoes and peppers with a delightful "sweet-hot" taste. Give your pork, chicken or cream cheese a savory flare with this Tomato Hot Pepper Jelly

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Tomatoes, chili peppers, cane sugar, vinegar & pectin.

    Learn More
  6. Heinie-Hurtin Hot Sauce & Jelly - 8 ounce jar
    $5.99

    SKU:JE65

    Market Price $6.99

    Our Low Price $5.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $14.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $47.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $3.99

    Heinie Hurtin’ Hot Sauce & Jelly- Multiple national champion hot sauce & jelly. An exciting combo of sweet & hot, this sauce is extremely good served on the side with chicken, pork or lamb, add to eggs, hamburgers, hot dogs, or serve alone as a fabulous pretzel dip. Be creative! Make the world's easiest hors d'oeuvre by taking a brick of cream cheese, pour a jar of hot sauce of the the cream cheese serve with crackers of your choice.

    Awards:

    • 2005 NBBQA Championship - Won 4th place - Add Ons: Condiments1996 Philadelphia Summer Fancy Food Show Focused Tasting 1st Place Winner.
    • 1997 Philadelphia Food & Wine Festival 1st place winner.
    • 1999 National Champion at the National Fiery Food Show in Albuquerque, NM.
    • 2000 Three Category Champion at the Emmaus, PA Hot Sauce Festival.
    • 2001 National Barbecue Assoc. - Best Hot Sauce 3rd Place.

    Made for Peppers in Lewes, DE

    Ingredients: Sugar, Jalapeño Peppers, apple cider vinegar & pectin.

    Learn More
  7. It's Spicy Peanut Butter Jelly Time - 2 Pack Gift Set
    $14.98

    SKU:GIFT78

    Market Price $16.98

    Our Low Price $14.98

    SAVE $2.00

    It's Spicy Peanut Butter Jelly Time - 2 Pack Gift Set includes: Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter & Backyard Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly 

     

    Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter - Salty and spicy, Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter is an all-natural, creamy peanut butter made with Ass Kickin' Peanuts. This medium-heat peanut butter adds a fun kick to PB&J and other recipes when swapped out for regular peanut butter. Try using it in a Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe. Ingredients: Peanuts roasted in peanut oil with added salt, spices, Habaero Pepper & extractive of paprika. From Arizona

     

    Backyard Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly - Sweet and heat made from a winning mix of strawberries and peppers with a delightful "sweet-hot" taste. Give your pork, chicken or cream cheese a home sweet home flair with the Strawberry Hot Pepper Jelly. Ingredients: Strawberries, Chili peppers, cane sugar, vinegar & pectin. From Delaware

     


     

      Learn More
  8. Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Sweet Tater Butter - 9.5 ounce jar
    $7.99

    SKU:JE79

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $7.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $20.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $6.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $71.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Sweet Tater Butter - "The Taste of Tennessee Hill Country Whiskey!" This old-fashioned Sweet Tater Butter jelly will remind you of being at your Grandma's house for breakfast. It tastes excellent on biscuits, toast or bagels. The blend of sweet potatoes, honey, and molasses along with Jack Daniel's Whiskey brings a one of a kind flavor to your breakfast table.

    From Tennessee

    Ingredients: Pure cane sugar, sweet potatoes, citrus juice, honey, molasses, vinegar, fruit pectin, spices, natural flavor & Jack Daniel's Whiskey. 

     

    Learn More
  9. Robert Rothschild Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserves - 12.7 ounce jar
    $6.99

    SKU:JE78

    Market Price $7.99

    Our Low Price $6.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $17.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $59.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Robert Rothschild Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserves - A savory blend of raspberries and Red Chili peppers. Serve over a bed of cream cheese or over warm brie accompanied by crackers. Use as a basting sauce over chicken or ham. Warm and use as a dip for chicken fingers.

    From Ohio

    Ingredients: Sugar, red Raspberries, fruit pectin and crushed Red Chili peppers.

    Learn More
  10. Terrapin Ridge Farms Hot Pepper Bacon Jam - 11 ounce jar
    $7.99

    SKU:JE80

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $7.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $20.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $6.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $71.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Terrapin Ridge Farms Hot Pepper Bacon Jam - Roasted Red Pepper puree, Jalapeo peppers and real bacon combine to create an addictive jam. For a quick appetizer, pour over cream cheese and serve with crackers. Use straight out of the jar as a dip. Pairs perfectly with strong cheeses. Delicious served with grilled fish and chicken or as a condiment on a sandwich, wrap or Panini.

    From Florida

    Ingredients: Sugar, Roasted Red peppers, Jalapeo peppers, bacon, lemon juice, pectin, salt, distilled Vinegar, citric acid, natural flavoring including smoke, brown sugar & tumeric.

    Learn More

Grid List

Set Descending Direction

1-10 of 37

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Our Hottest Peppers

Scorpion Pepper

Scorpion Pepper

Shop Scorpion Sauces

Reaper Pepper

Reaper Pepper

Shop Reaper Sauces

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Signup for our newsletter to receive regular Peppers.com news, specials and promotions.

Fill out my online form.

What The Media Says

  • Probably the most unique store in this part of the country.

    PBS
  • Chip globe-trots in search of new hot sauces ... thus giving him the largest collection in the world according to Chili Pepper Magazine.

    The Washington Post
  • Chip has also created a museum of hot sauces ... If you want to have a hot time in Dewey Beach, Delaware.

    TNN
  • One of the best 202 things about the South. You don't have to bask in the sun to get some heat on Rehoboth Beach this summer. Just step...

    Southern Living
  • First-prize winner at the Fiery Foods Show was Peppers' Georgia Peach and Vidalia Onion.

    The New York Times
  • Our guest Chip Hearn ... publisher of Peppers Catalog and heating up with the hottest sauces.

    Food Network
  • For lovers of hot sauce, this place is heaven.

    The Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Where you can buy any hot sauce made by man.

    Good Morning America
  • Chip Hearn of Peppers, a retail store and hot sauce museum in Rehoboth Beach, DE, which carries 2,000 hot sauce brands.

    Advertising Age
  • Chip Hearn is a hothead. Because everyone has a different threshold for heat, Hearn uses his entire management staff as tasters.

    The Tampa Tribune
  • We've been talking about them all week long. Today's the day we're ready to cook with hot sauce. We've got Chip Hearn here...

    NBC
  • Chip Hearn's hot-sauce empire peddles some 3,000 mixtures of bottled heat. More amazing is that he's sample nearly all of them.

    The Boston Globe