Free shipping for continental U.S. orders over $69.00. Call us at 800-998-3473 for rates to Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico & Canada.

Mustard

Add a new twist on all your recipes that ask for mustard! Use a stout, smokey or horseradish based mustard to liven up your sandwich, deviled eggs, or honey mustard. Some of the mustards included are Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Horseradish Mustard and Robert Rothschild Anna Mae’s Smoky Mustard!

Grid List

Set Descending Direction

1-10 of 13

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  1. Backyard Country Apricot Mustard - 9.1 ounce jar
    $8.49

    SKU:MU6A

    Our Low Price $8.49

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $22.47 - Save $3.00 Bottle Price $7.49

    Fantastic Price for 12 Bottles $77.88 - Save $24.00 Bottle Price $6.49

    Backyard Country Apricot Mustard - From Backyard Jams and Jellies, Krista Scudlark has created this sweet and tangy mustard. It adds great gourmet flavor to any sandwich, potato salad or even as a glaze for holiday ham.

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Vinegar, dry mustard, sugar, butter, eggs, salt & herbs.

    Learn More
  2. Backyard Brown Ale Mustard - 9.7 ounce jar
    $7.99

    SKU:MU6B

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $7.99

    Special Price for 3 Bottles $20.97 - Save $6.00 Bottle Price $6.99

    Backyard Brown Ale Mustard - From Backyard Jams and Jellies, Krista Scudlark has created this savory, sweet and tangy mustard. It adds great gourmet flavor to any sandwich, potato salad or even as a glaze for holiday ham. 

    From Delaware

    Ingredients: Mustard seed, Dogfish Indian Brown Dark IPA, cider vinegar, Backyard Extra Hot Pepper Jelly, brown sugar, garlic, herbs, corn starch, salt & pepper.

    Learn More
  3. Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard  10.7 ounce jar
    $7.99

    SKU:MU23

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $7.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $20.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $6.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $71.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard - The rich flavor of pecans give unique flavor to our sweet and tangy honey mustard. The perfect accompaniment for cheeses and to glaze meats and vegetables. Makes an incredible baked brie. Use as a sauce for pork tenderloin or roast turkey. Drizzle on squash, carrots and sweet potatoes. Also, wonderful as a pretzel dip.

    All Natural, Gluten Free, Fat Free

    From Florida

    Ingredients: Honey mustard, pecan meal, almond extract, ground cinnamon & ground cloves.

    Learn More
  4. Sierra Nevada Stout & Stoneground Mustard-8 Ounce Jar
    $6.99

    SKU:MU11

    Market Price $7.99

    Our Low Price $6.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $17.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $59.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $4.99

     

    Sierra Nevada Stout & Stone Ground Mustard - One of America's premier specialty brewers is proud to bring you this savory mustard made with all natural ingredients and award winning ales. Enjoy as a mustard, dipping sauce or glaze.

    From California

    Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, mustard seed, salt, stout, spices.

    Learn More
  5. Sierra Nevada Porter & Spicy Brown Mustard-8 Ounce Jar
    $6.99

    SKU:MU112

    Market Price $7.99

    Our Low Price $6.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $17.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $59.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $4.99

     

    Sierra Nevada Porter & Spicy Brown Mustard - One of America's premier specialty brewers is proud to bring you this savory mustard made with all natural ingredients and their award winning Porter. Enjoy as a mustard, dipping sauce or glaze.

    From California

    Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, mustard seed, salt, porter, spices.

    Learn More
  6. Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Spiced Curry Mustard - 8 ounce jar
    $5.99

    SKU:MU61

    Market Price $6.99

    Our Low Price $5.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $14.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $47.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $3.99

    Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Spiced Curry Mustard - A smooth mustard that delivers a subtle curry flavor supported by premium Tennessee whiskey. It dates back thousands of years to the early Romans. Lynchburg has developed their mustard with the taste enjoyed thru the centuries with one additional "Kiss of Tennessee Whiskey". They hope you enjoy their mustard with your family and friends. Tastes Great On: Wieners, Sausages, Hot Dogs, Bratwurst, Frankfurters, Hamburgers, Corn Dogs, Deli Sandwiches and French Fries

    From Tennessee

    Ingredients: Apple Cider and distilled vinegar, mustard seed, white wine, Boyle's curry powder, salt, spices, canola oil & Jack Daniel's Whiskey.

    Learn More
  7. Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Horseradish Mustard - 8 ounce jar
    $5.99

    SKU:MU62

    Market Price $6.99

    Our Low Price $5.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $14.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $47.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $3.99

    Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Horseradish Mustard - A brilliant, sharp horseradish mustard with smoky notes of Jack Daniels Premium Tennessee Whiskey. It dates back thousands of years to the early Romans. Lynchburg has developed their mustard with the taste enjoyed thru the centuries with one additional "Kiss of Tennessee Whiskey". They hope you enjoy their mustard with your family and friends. Tastes Great On: Wieners, Sausages, Hot Dogs, Bratwurst, Frankfurters, Hamburgers, Corn Dogs, Deli Sandwiches and French Fries

    From Tennessee

    Ingredients: Apple Cider and distilled vinegar, mustard seed, white wine, horseradish, salt, garlic, cane sugar, onion, spices, Black Pepper, allspice & Jack Daniel's Whiskey.

    Learn More
  8. Daves Gourmet Hurtin Habaero & Honey Mustard - 8 ounce jar
    $7.99

    SKU:MU27

    Market Price $8.99

    Our Low Price $7.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $20.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $6.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $71.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Dave's Gourmet Hurtin' Habaero & Honey Mustard - "It hurts so good!" Dave has really done it with this painful mustard. It is a delicious blend of Habaero and red Chili peppers, light golden honey and selected spices, that will heat up your taste buds. "This product may be addictive to those with tastebuds, but don't worry, they'll make more". This mustard is very hot and makes a great sauce base. Spread on your favorite sandwich, brush on your grilled meats as a marinade or add to your salad dressings.

    Awards:

    • 2007 Napa Valley Mustard Festival - Gold Medal in Hot Pepper Category (also won Gold Medals in 2001, 2002, 2003, 2005 and Silver Medal in 2004)
    • 2004 Scovie Awards, won 1st Place in the Condiments - Mustards Category
    • 2002 Worldwide Mustard Competition, won Gold Medal in the Hot Pepper Category
    • 2001 NASFT, won 1st Place in the Outstanding Savory Condiment Category
    • 2001 Worldwide Mustard Competition, won Gold Medal in the Hot Pepper Category

    From California.

    Ingredients: Red Chili Peppers, honey, sugar, mustard seed, white distilled vinegar, wheat flour, salt, Habaero Peppers, garlic, lemon juice, paprika, onions, soybean oil, tumeric, annatto, spice & natural flavor.

    Learn More
  9. Cherchies Champagne Brand Mustard - 8 ounce jar
    $6.99

    SKU:MU10

    Market Price $7.99

    Our Low Price $6.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $17.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $59.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Cherchies Champagne Brand Mustard - This delicious mustard was a medal winner at the 2012 World Wide Mustard Competition. Discover for yourself this hot/sweet classic Champagne Mustard. Try it as a dip using pretzels or cheese, on sandwiches or to baste a ham and in countless other recipes.

    Gluten Free - High Fructose Corn Syrup Free

    From Pennsylvania

    Ingredients: Sugar, vinegars (white and champagne), eggs & mustard flour.

    Learn More
  10. Bone Suckin’ Sweet Spicy Mustard - 12 ounce jar
    $6.99

    SKU:MU8

    Market Price $7.99

    Our Low Price $6.99

    Special Price for 3 Jars $17.97 - Save $6.00 Jar Price $5.99

    Fantastic Price for 12 Jars $59.88 - Save $36.00 Jar Price $4.99

    Bone Suckin' Sweet Spicy Mustard - The perfect blend of brown sugar, molasses, and paprika with the subtle heat of Jalapeños. This medium heat mustard is perfect for grilling, dipping, and even straight off the spoon.Sweet Hot Yum! It's turning the BBQ world upside down! So good you'll want to suck the bones and bread. Fantastic on ham, biscuits, grilled cheese & even hot dogs! Tickles the senses while it warms the tummy! This Kosher Certified mustard will keep you coming back for more! Mix with cream cheese & diced onions for a bagel spread. Use amply for that Bone Suckin' Mustard flavor. Also great on ribs, beef, pork, chicken, seafood, quiche, vegetables, salads, dipping, stir fry & cheeses

    ALL NATURAL, NO PRESERVATIVES, GLUTEN FREE, CERTIFIED KOSHER, AND PAREVE

    Awards:

    • Great American Barbecue Contest, Kansas City - 1st Place Winner (Highest score of all mustards).
    • 2003 Fiery Food Challenge, won 2nd place!             

    From North Carolina

    Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, #1 grade mustard seed, brown sugar, molasses, Jalapeño peppers, cornstarch, tumeric, paprika, spices, garlic powder & natural flavor.

    Learn More

Grid List

Set Descending Direction

1-10 of 13

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2

Our Hottest Peppers

Scorpion Pepper

Scorpion Pepper

Shop Scorpion Sauces

Reaper Pepper

Reaper Pepper

Shop Reaper Sauces

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Signup for our newsletter to receive regular Peppers.com news, specials and promotions.

Fill out my online form.

What The Media Says

  • Our guest Chip Hearn ... publisher of Peppers Catalog and heating up with the hottest sauces.

    Food Network
  • Chip Hearn of Peppers, a retail store and hot sauce museum in Rehoboth Beach, DE, which carries 2,000 hot sauce brands.

    Advertising Age
  • Chip Hearn is a hothead. Because everyone has a different threshold for heat, Hearn uses his entire management staff as tasters.

    The Tampa Tribune
  • Probably the most unique store in this part of the country.

    PBS
  • Chip Hearn's hot-sauce empire peddles some 3,000 mixtures of bottled heat. More amazing is that he's sample nearly all of them.

    The Boston Globe
  • Chip has also created a museum of hot sauces ... If you want to have a hot time in Dewey Beach, Delaware.

    TNN
  • We've been talking about them all week long. Today's the day we're ready to cook with hot sauce. We've got Chip Hearn here...

    NBC
  • Chip globe-trots in search of new hot sauces ... thus giving him the largest collection in the world according to Chili Pepper Magazine.

    The Washington Post
  • Where you can buy any hot sauce made by man.

    Good Morning America
  • First-prize winner at the Fiery Foods Show was Peppers' Georgia Peach and Vidalia Onion.

    The New York Times
  • For lovers of hot sauce, this place is heaven.

    The Philadelphia Inquirer
  • One of the best 202 things about the South. You don't have to bask in the sun to get some heat on Rehoboth Beach this summer. Just step...

    Southern Living